Second Degree Reckless Injury Defense Lawyer in Wisconsin

Charged with Second-Degree Reckless Injury under Wis. Stat. § 940.23(2)? This violent felony allegation focuses on whether your conduct was criminally reckless and caused great bodily harm. Call Chirafisi Anderson, S.C. to start your defense – Free Consultations

What the Law Says About Second Degree Reckless Injury in Wisconsin

Under Wis. Stat. § 940.23(2), a person commits Second Degree Reckless Injury if they recklessly cause great bodily harm to another human being. Unlike first-degree reckless injury, this offense does not require proof that the conduct occurred under circumstances showing utter disregard for human life.

The statute also applies when reckless conduct causes great bodily harm to an unborn child, as set forth in Wis. Stat. § 940.23(2)(b). Second Degree Reckless Injury in one of Wisconsin’s violent crimes and focuses on criminal recklessness – risk creation and awareness – without the additional aggravating factor that elevates the offense to first degree.

Learn more about Reckless Injury in Wisconsin.

What the State Must Prove to Convict on Second Degree Reckless Injury

o convict a defendant of Second Degree Reckless Injury under Wis. Stat. § 940.23(2), the State must prove each element beyond a reasonable doubt:

  1. The defendant caused great bodily harm to the alleged victim.
    • “Cause” means the act was a substantial factor in producing the harm.
    • “Great bodily harm” means serious bodily injury (which includes injury creating a substantial risk of death, serious permanent disfigurement, or permanent/protracted loss or impairment of a bodily member or organ).
  2. Criminally Reckless Conduct
    • The conduct created a risk of death or great bodily harm,
    • The risk was unreasonable and substantial, and
    • The defendant was aware that their conduct created that unreasonable and substantial risk.

Unlike first-degree reckless injury, the State is not required to prove that the circumstances showed utter disregard for human life.

These elements are detailed in Wisconsin Jury Instruction – Criminal 1252 Second Degree Reckless Injury

Penalties and Sentencing for Second Degree Reckless Injury in Wisconsin

Second Degree Reckless Injury is a Class F felony under Wisconsin law.

  • Up to 12 years, 6 months imprisonment (7.5 years imprisonment and 5 years extended supervision)
  • Up to $25,000 in fines

In determining sentence length and structure, courts commonly consider the severity of the injury, how the risk was created (including use of a weapon, vehicle, or force), proximity of others to danger, and the defendant’s awareness of the risk. Judges also evaluate conduct before, during, and after the incident, including any efforts to render aid or mitigate harm.

Second Degree Reckless Injury Attorneys in Wisconsin Free Consultations
REQUEST A FREE AND CONFIDENTIAL CONSULTATION
New Website Intake

Common Scenarios in Wisconsin Second Degree Reckless Injury Cases

Second Degree Reckless Injury charges are commonly filed when serious injury results from dangerous conduct, but prosecutors do not allege circumstances showing utter disregard for human life. Typical scenarios include:

  • Firearm mishandling or a single reckless discharge causing serious injury
  • High-risk driving (speeding, OWI, racing) resulting in fractures, head trauma, or other serious injuries
  • Physical altercations that escalate to great bodily harm without proof of “utter disregard”
  • Dangerous tools, fires, or explosives used recklessly, causing lasting injury
  • Domestic disputes where actions unintentionally cause great bodily harm

In these cases, disputes often focus on whether the defendant was aware of the risk created and whether the injury meets the statutory definition of great bodily harm.

Defenses and Legal Strategies for Second Degree Reckless Injury

Defending a Second Degree Reckless Injury charge centers on whether the State can prove criminal recklessness, awareness of risk, and great bodily harm beyond a reasonable doubt. Effective defense strategies often include:

  • Causation not proven — The act was not a substantial factor in causing the injury.
  • No “great bodily harm” — Medical records and expert review may show injuries do not reach the statutory threshold.
  • No subjective awareness — Evidence fails to prove the defendant knew of the unreasonable and substantial risk.
  • Self-defense / defense of others — Conduct was lawful under § 939.48.
  • Overcharging / charge reduction — Facts may support Negligent Handling of a Weapon or Battery rather than a Class F felony.

Why Hiring a Second Degree Reckless Injury Lawyer Matters

Second Degree Reckless Injury is a serious violent felony that can carry years of prison exposure and long-term collateral consequences. These cases often turn on close factual questions—whether the defendant was truly aware of the risk, whether the conduct rose to the level of criminal recklessness, and whether the injury meets the statutory definition of great bodily harm.

Local Experience matters. The attorneys at Chirafisi Anderson, S.C. regularly defend reckless injury and other violent-felony cases throughout Southern and Central Wisconsin. Our familiarity with local charging practices and courtroom expectations informs how these cases are evaluated and litigated.

Proven track record of results. Our firm has obtained dismissals, charge reductions, and favorable resolutions by challenging causation, disputing injury classifications, and rebutting allegations of criminal recklessness.

Recognized legal excellence. Attorneys at Chirafisi Anderson, S.C. are recognized by Super Lawyers® and are active members of WACDL and NACDL, reflecting a commitment to careful preparation and effective advocacy in felony cases.


Second Degree Reckless Injury Case Results

  • 2nd Degree Reckless Injury – Dane County (April 2023)

    Result: Case Dismissed

View more case results from our attorneys.


Contact Chirafisi Anderson, S.C.

A Second Degree Reckless Injury charge raises serious questions about risk, awareness, and the extent of the alleged injury. How the facts are evaluated early can determine whether the charge proceeds as filed, is reduced, or is dismissed.

Chirafisi Anderson, S.C. represents individuals charged with Second Degree Reckless Injury and other violent felony offenses throughout Southern and Central Wisconsin, including Dane, Rock, Iowa, Green, Columbia, Dodge, Jefferson, and Sauk Counties.

Frequently asked questions – Second Degree Reckless Injury

First-degree adds “utter disregard for human life” and is a Class D felony. Second-degree is Class F and focuses on criminal recklessness without that aggravating element.

No. The State must prove criminal recklessness (awareness of an unreasonable and substantial risk), not an intent to harm.

Medical proof of great bodily harm, video and witness accounts of how risk was created, and evidence of the defendant’s awareness (or lack thereof).

Generally no. Voluntary intoxication does not excuse criminal recklessness under Wisconsin law.

Potentially. Where great bodily harm isn’t proven or awareness/risk is weak, cases can be reduced to Battery or Negligent Handling (or resolved via deferred outcomes), depending on the facts and venue.